RPG grinding
A systematic RPG grind reference: 110 mechanics and 330 variants in 18 sections. Four layers answer different questions: what the player repeats, what develops, how rewards arrive and what constrains the loop. It covers single-player RPGs, ARPGs, MMORPGs and adjacent management and accumulation systems. Every mechanic has an explanation, variants and a hypothetical example; coverage, combinations and verified game observations follow the catalog.
No matches
Change your query or reset the filters.
Activities
Combat and hunting
1Targeted boss farmingOverview and example ↗The player chooses an enemy with a known loot table and repeats the fight for a particular item.3
Action → reward
- Defeat a chosen boss repeatedly → get attempts at obtaining a desired item.
- Choose an available boss version by its loot table.
- Collect summoning materials for repeat attempts.
Design example. An ice guardian can drop a cold-resistant shield, so the player returns before entering a snowy region.
2Hunting for ingredientsOverview and example ↗A required material is tied to a creature, location or hunting condition, directing target selection.3
Action → reward
- Track particular creatures → obtain crafting parts.
- Hunt in a biome containing the desired material.
- Gather different ingredients for one production chain.
Design example. A frost potion needs cave-lizard glands, so the player searches for their lairs.
3Enemy-pack farmingOverview and example ↗The player gathers and defeats ordinary enemy packs, choosing density, routing and resource expenditure.3
Variants
- Gather enemies for area attacks.
- Repeat a short route between camps.
- Choose safe packs over denser dangerous ones.
Design example. A mage draws several squads onto a bridge and spends one powerful attack on the whole pack.
4Rare and elite huntingOverview and example ↗An attempt's value depends on locating a special target rather than merely maximizing kills.3
Variants
- Check known spawn locations.
- Follow clues leading to a rare target.
- Share sightings within a party.
Design example. A scout checks three dens and changes region if the rare beast has not appeared.
5Part-break harvestingOverview and example ↗The player changes combat tactics to damage a desired part and obtain its associated material.3
Variants
- Break a specific part before victory.
- Use a suitable damage type to sever material.
- Preserve a rare organ by avoiding excessive damage.
Design example. A hunter targets the shell, keeping the prey alive until it breaks.
6Live captureOverview and example ↗A repeated hunt ends in capture; preparation and timing differ from an ordinary finishing blow.3
Variants
- Weaken the target and apply a trap.
- Sedate creatures for breeding.
- Transport captured prey under capacity limits.
Design example. The player weakens a beast, traps it and delivers it to researchers.
7Combat target chainsOverview and example ↗One victory unlocks or strengthens the next target, forming a repeatable sequence.3
Variants
- Build a summoning chain from trophies.
- Progress through increasingly strong targets.
- Hunt a chosen chain branch for its rewards.
Design example. After three guards, a captain appears; the captain's token summons a champion.
8Recurring area clearingOverview and example ↗The player clears a territory's locations in sequence, after which the world rules restore the loop.3
Variants
- Clear connected camps along a route.
- Capture locations until a shared reward appears.
- Choose between a full clear and selected valuable locations.
Design example. Clearing four outposts unlocks a reward convoy before the cycle restarts.
Repeatable challenges
9Scaling dungeonsOverview and example ↗A familiar dungeon is completed at higher difficulty tiers for the next level of rewards.3
Action → reward
- Repeat runs at higher tiers → obtain stronger rewards.
- Add modifiers changing the run and its rewards.
- Repeat a chosen tier for reliable acquisition.
Design example. A successful clear unlocks a tier with new enemy modifiers and stronger loot.
10Endless wavesOverview and example ↗The player survives successive waves and decides whether the extra reward is worth the next stage’s risk.3
Action → reward
- Survive the assault longer → reach further reward thresholds.
- Choose a reward or upgrade between waves.
- Stop a run at a convenient threshold.
Design example. After every fifth wave, the party can claim its loot or stay for the next chest.
11Repeatable contracts and bountiesOverview and example ↗Short assignments refresh targets within a familiar action set. Rewards connect individual expeditions to a long-term goal.3
Action → reward
- Complete repeatable tasks with different targets → earn money, experience and materials.
- Choose a contract by desired material or enemy.
- Combine compatible contracts into one route.
Design example. A bounty board offers hunts for different monster types, letting the player choose the reward they need.
12Repeated raid clearsOverview and example ↗A group repeats a multi-stage challenge, allocating roles, loot and available attempts.3
Variants
- Clear a full raid for its final reward.
- Repeat an available individual encounter.
- Build a stable group to reduce losses between attempts.
Design example. A party starts at its desired raid boss using saved progress from earlier encounters.
13World-event cyclesOverview and example ↗Repeated events change local world state and unlock later objectives or rewards.3
Variants
- Join a sequence of shared events.
- Rotate through independent events.
- Prepare an event through supplies or scouting.
Design example. Defending a village starts a counterattack that unlocks a shared boss.
14Cumulative PvP progressionOverview and example ↗Matches award experience, currency or participation marks separately from competitive skill rating.3
Variants
- Accumulate currency from completed matches.
- Advance a reward track through useful actions.
- Collect victory marks for a special reward.
Design example. A player earns tokens for contributing to objective control even when their team loses.
15Repeatable skill trialsOverview and example ↗A familiar trial tests execution and awards completion of specified conditions.3
Variants
- Finish within a target time.
- Complete combat with restricted tools.
- Achieve a streak of error-free clears.
Design example. The player repeats an obstacle course to finish without falling and earn a mastery badge.
16Procedural expeditionsOverview and example ↗The same objective repeats across changing routes, encounters and resources.3
Variants
- Explore newly assembled dungeons.
- Choose a route from randomized nodes.
- Take temporary upgrades within a run.
Design example. Each mine expedition changes its forks, while its ore contributes to one long-term building project.
Gathering and production
17Gathering routesOverview and example ↗The player repeats a route through gathering nodes and optimizes visit order, carrying capacity and return trips.3
Action → reward
- Visit mineral deposits, plants and other nodes → accumulate raw materials.
- Change routes when nodes deplete or become occupied.
- Choose a tool for resource quality and yield.
Design example. An herbalist plans a loop through a swamp to gather ingredients and return to an alchemy table.
18Loot salvagingOverview and example ↗Unwanted loot becomes materials for another progression path. An item’s value also depends on its salvage yield.3
Action → reward
- Collect unwanted equipment → turn it into materials for useful equipment.
- Salvage items for a rare component.
- Choose between selling, salvaging and using an item.
Design example. Spare armor is salvaged into ingots used to strengthen a chosen chest piece.
19Production chainsOverview and example ↗A final item requires multiple processing stages. The player accumulates raw materials and intermediate components.3
Action → reward
- Gather raw materials, process them and assemble components → craft valuable items.
- Accumulate components for multiple stages in parallel.
- Replace a scarce component through an alternative recipe.
Design example. Ore becomes ingots, ingots become plates, and plates plus leather become armor.
20Consumable supplyOverview and example ↗Supplies used on adventures run out regularly. Replenishing them connects preparation to repeated gathering.3
Action → reward
- Gather ingredients and prepare supplies → replenish potions, food and ammunition.
- Prepare consumables for a particular challenge.
- Choose inexpensive stock or a powerful rare effect.
Design example. Before an expedition, the party gathers herbs and prepares healing potions for several fights.
21Fishing and aquatic gatheringOverview and example ↗The player repeats catches while choosing tackle, bait, location and conditions.3
Variants
- Choose bait for a desired species.
- Accumulate catches for sale or cooking.
- Seek trophy size and quality.
Design example. A fisher changes bait and travels to a river mouth for a rare eel.
22Crop cultivationOverview and example ↗Planting, tending and harvesting form a recurring cycle converting seeds and time into produce.3
Variants
- Grow crops for recipes.
- Rotate plantings for steady yield.
- Select seeds for the next harvest.
Design example. The player alternates fast herbs and slow fruit crops for different orders.
23Livestock careOverview and example ↗Repeated care sustains renewable animal products.3
Variants
- Feed animals for regular produce.
- Improve care and product quality.
- Maintain livestock within space and feed limits.
Design example. The player stocks feed and chooses whether to sell milk or process it into cheese.
24Quality-focused craftingOverview and example ↗Repeated crafting targets result quality determined by process or expenditure.3
Variants
- Choose an operation sequence for quality.
- Use higher-quality raw materials.
- Rework poor batches into useful components.
Design example. A crafter spends better blanks on an order requiring precise workmanship.
Exploration and discovery
25Treasure-map huntingOverview and example ↗A consumable map or clue set directs a repeatable expedition toward a cache.3
Variants
- Decode cache coordinates.
- Follow a sequence of landmarks.
- Combine map fragments for a valuable expedition.
Design example. The player matches a rock silhouette to the landscape and digs up a chest.
26Archaeology and excavationOverview and example ↗Finding traces, locating sites and excavating yield materials or historical collection pieces.3
Variants
- Survey sites and narrow the search area.
- Excavate carefully to preserve an item.
- Restore finds from several excavations.
Design example. An archaeologist surveys ruins with a device and chooses a dig site by signal strength.
27Chest and cache circuitsOverview and example ↗The player repeats a circuit of replenishing caches, balancing access, risk and route speed.3
Variants
- Visit known loot locations.
- Find hidden caches through sound or traces.
- Choose tools for locks and obstacles.
Design example. A rooftop route reaches several caches without combat.
28Theft and smugglingOverview and example ↗Repeated acquisition relies on stealth, detection risk and disposal of stolen goods.3
Variants
- Pick pockets under escalating risk.
- Infiltrate buildings for valuables.
- Move contraband through checkpoints.
Design example. A thief chooses between safe pockets and a guarded till, then seeks a fence.
29Repeatable puzzles and routesOverview and example ↗Navigation or reasoning challenges repeat with rewards, changing conditions or target sets.3
Variants
- Solve random configurations of a familiar puzzle.
- Complete a route with rearranged targets.
- Collect a reward for completing an entire series.
Design example. A maze rearranges passages while recovered seals contribute to a shared amulet.
30Condition-dependent gatheringOverview and example ↗A desired resource is available under particular weather, time or environmental conditions.3
Variants
- Visit locations in suitable weather.
- Track daily environmental windows.
- Change environmental state to reveal a resource.
Design example. Night dew appears on cliffs after rain, changing an alchemist's route.
Trade and economy
31Money farmingOverview and example ↗The player chooses repeatable activities by net currency income after expenses.3
Variants
- Sell ordinary loot to vendors.
- Complete fixed-pay jobs.
- Choose money sources by net income per session.
Design example. A mercenary compares contract pay against repair and potion costs.
32Trade routesOverview and example ↗Goods are bought or produced in one place and transported to a more valuable destination.3
Variants
- Transport goods between regions.
- Build a circuit without an empty return leg.
- Protect cargo to preserve profit.
Design example. A caravan carries salt to a mountain town, choosing a toll road or dangerous pass.
33Resale and arbitrageOverview and example ↗Progress comes from price differences after fees, demand, risk and tied-up capital.3
Variants
- Buy underpriced listings and resell.
- Use price differences between markets.
- Hold stock until demand changes.
Design example. A trader buys cheap reagents and sells them where a potion order has raised demand.
34Market-oriented productionOverview and example ↗The player repeats production for profit, choosing volume and assortment according to demand.3
Variants
- Sell consumables with recurring demand.
- Produce small batches of rare goods.
- Switch production when margins fall.
Design example. A smith makes inexpensive tools when rare armor sells too slowly.
35Service ordersOverview and example ↗Repeated services for characters or players pay for skill, conditions fulfilled or delivery.3
Variants
- Craft from a customer's materials.
- Provide paid transport or escort.
- Repair, enchant or process another person's item.
Design example. An alchemist accepts an antidote order using the customer's materials.
36Currency and material conversionOverview and example ↗An accumulated resource converts into another through a fixed rate, recipe or market.3
Variants
- Exchange currencies at a vendor.
- Process materials into more liquid goods.
- Choose a valuable use for a shared resource.
Design example. The player exchanges spare old-zone tokens for current crafting reagents.
Delegation and automation
37Worker assignmentOverview and example ↗The player allocates workers to tasks while maintaining resources, efficiency and work queues.3
Variants
- Assign a specialist to a suitable resource.
- Reassign workers to a production bottleneck.
- Supply workers with food, tools or rest.
Design example. A lumberjack takes a nearby node while an experienced miner gathers rare ore.
38Dispatch missionsOverview and example ↗A prepared squad performs a task without direct control; the player chooses composition, investment and duration.3
Variants
- Match the squad to mission requirements.
- Choose a short or long expedition.
- Improve equipment to unlock new outcomes.
Design example. Two scouts seek maps while the hero explores a dungeon.
39Passive productionOverview and example ↗A built system produces resources over time while inputs and storage remain available.3
Variants
- Start a processing queue.
- Connect automated production stages.
- Resolve stoppages caused by inputs or storage.
Design example. A mill processes grain until flour storage fills.
40Offline accumulationOverview and example ↗The system awards bounded progress during absence, with explicit simulation rules and caps.3
Variants
- Accumulate resources up to a defined cap.
- Choose an active task before leaving.
- Improve offline production speed or capacity.
Design example. On returning, the player receives ore from several hours of mine operation.
41Production logisticsOverview and example ↗Repeated movement of resources between nodes determines production throughput.3
Variants
- Configure raw-material transport routes.
- Allocate storage buffers between stages.
- Increase throughput at the slowest stage.
Design example. The player adds a cart between mine and smithy to keep the furnace running.
Goals
Character progression
42Experience levelingOverview and example ↗Repeated actions award experience that raises character level and unlocks attributes or abilities.3
Action → reward
- Defeat enemies and complete quests → earn experience and gain levels.
- Earn experience from peaceful activities and discoveries.
- Choose quests by experience relative to risk and time.
Design example. Clearing a camp awards experience; the next level grants a point to spend on an ability.
43Learning by using skillsOverview and example ↗A skill develops through its associated action. Award rules determine which attempts count as useful practice.3
Action → reward
- Pick locks, cast spells or sneak → improve the corresponding skill.
- Develop a skill only on suitably difficult tasks.
- Vary application situations to continue progressing.
Design example. Picking an unfamiliar lock improves lockpicking; reopening the same lock grants no experience.
44Weapon proficiencyOverview and example ↗Using a chosen weapon type advances a separate proficiency track and unlocks related techniques.3
Action → reward
- Fight with a particular weapon type → unlock techniques and proficiency bonuses.
- Unlock a technique by completing a weapon challenge.
- Master separate stances for one weapon.
Design example. Victories with a spear fill a proficiency track, letting the player choose a new attack against shields.
45Profession levelingOverview and example ↗Gathering and crafting raise a profession rank and expand the available recipes or resources.3
Action → reward
- Craft items, brew potions or mine ore → gain access to advanced recipes.
- Complete profession orders for rank.
- Master new recipe categories instead of producing cheap duplicates.
Design example. A smith completes iron-tool orders, raises their rank and unlocks a steel-blade recipe.
46Mastery across classes and equipmentOverview and example ↗Developing new classes or equipment contributes to shared progression. Rules for counting new items encourage trying different play styles.3
Action → reward
- Level new classes or items → raise an overall rank and unlock options.
- Develop different classes for an overall rank.
- Complete a set of mastered items for a shared unlock.
Design example. Mastering each staff type for the first time grants overall rank points; mastering a duplicate adds none.
47Post-cap progressionOverview and example ↗After the main level track ends, experience feeds a separate long-term system without necessarily resetting the hero.3
Variants
- Accumulate points on a post-cap track.
- Choose permanent specializations after reaching maximum level.
- Develop separate endgame tracks with different goals.
Design example. At maximum level, experience unlocks extra passive-effect slots.
48Unlocking new classesOverview and example ↗Accumulated achievements or resources unlock new play styles rather than only raising current-class numbers.3
Variants
- Meet requirements for a new character class.
- Collect knowledge for a new specialization.
- Develop several base classes to unlock a hybrid.
Design example. Victories with different elements unlock a battle-mage school.
49Talent-track developmentOverview and example ↗Progress advances a chosen track, enabling specialization and comparison of alternative ability sets.3
Variants
- Advance a chosen track using accumulated points.
- Unlock nodes through thematically related actions.
- Redirect future progress into another track.
Design example. A warrior invests points in defense to unlock a new way of countering attacks.
Equipment acquisition
50Rarity huntingOverview and example ↗Repeated looting offers a chance to replace an item with a higher-quality or rarer version.3
Action → reward
- Collect random loot → find higher-quality items.
- Raise available quality through source difficulty.
- Collect rare items for different roles of one hero.
Design example. Fortress chests contain weapons of several rarities; the player seeks a rare version appropriate to their level.
51Hunting perfect rollsOverview and example ↗Copies of an item differ in their properties or values. The goal becomes a combination suited to a particular build.3
Action → reward
- Loot copies of an item → seek a desired combination of properties and values.
- Seek desired values on already suitable properties.
- Keep several combinations for different build tasks.
Design example. An archer seeks a ring with both attack speed and stamina recovery.
52Equipment set collectionOverview and example ↗Individual set pieces grant additional effects when used together. Progress is measured by set completion.3
Action → reward
- Obtain set pieces → unlock bonuses for wearing multiple pieces.
- Collect alternative sets for different roles.
- Combine partial bonuses from multiple sets.
Design example. Two set pieces strengthen poison, while the fourth changes how it spreads.
53Fragment collectionOverview and example ↗Parts of a future item accumulate toward a known threshold. Each acquired fragment brings a specific reward closer.3
Action → reward
- Accumulate shards or components → assemble an item upon reaching the threshold.
- Collect different named parts of one item.
- Choose which reward to assemble from shared fragments.
Design example. Each guardian victory grants a fragment; ten fragments assemble into an amulet.
54Crafting-base huntingOverview and example ↗The loot goal is a base with suitable inherent properties or crafting capacity.3
Variants
- Seek a suitable base type and level.
- Collect bases with desired sockets.
- Select bases by remaining upgrade capacity.
Design example. The player seeks a light blade with three sockets for a custom rune combination.
Equipment upgrades
55Equipment enhancementOverview and example ↗Materials are spent on successive enhancement levels of an existing item. Cost and success probability are separate design choices.3
Action → reward
- Gather materials → raise an item’s enhancement level.
- Raise levels with guaranteed results and increasing cost.
- Prepare protection materials before a risky upgrade.
Design example. The player gathers crystals and upgrades a sword from enhancement level three to four with guaranteed success.
56Property rerollingOverview and example ↗The player spends resources to replace properties on an acquired item and move it toward a desired configuration.3
Action → reward
- Spend accumulated resources → replace unwanted properties.
- Lock a useful property before rerolling the rest.
- Choose a replacement from several offers.
Design example. Enchantment dust replaces fire resistance with a random property while preserving the ring’s other attributes.
57Gem and rune upgradingOverview and example ↗Equipment inserts have their own acquisition and upgrade loop, with transfer between items governed by the game’s rules.3
Action → reward
- Collect and combine gems or runes → strengthen equipment inserts.
- Develop separate insert types for different builds.
- Unlock additional insert slots.
Design example. Three small rubies combine into one large ruby for a weapon socket.
58Item evolutionOverview and example ↗An item changes form or capabilities after its usage conditions are fulfilled.3
Action → reward
- Fulfill conditions with an equipped item → unlock its next form.
- Complete thematic challenges tied to an item.
- Choose among several evolution paths.
Design example. A staff awakens after being used to defeat spirits and gains a new spell.
59Duplicate fusionOverview and example ↗Duplicate copies are consumed to strengthen a chosen item, making duplicates a progression resource.3
Action → reward
- Obtain duplicate copies → consume them to develop the main item.
- Raise rank using copies from a defined group.
- Choose between fusion and keeping a copy for another build.
Design example. A duplicate talisman is consumed to raise the main talisman’s rank and increase its charge.
60Affix transferOverview and example ↗One item donates a property to another; the player acquires the base and desired effect separately.3
Variants
- Extract a property into a persistent library.
- Consume a donor item to transfer an effect.
- Combine a unique base with some properties from another item.
Design example. A rare axe is consumed to transfer its bleeding effect onto a preferred weapon.
61Crafting potentialOverview and example ↗Each craft consumes a limited item budget, making remaining crafting attempts part of a base's value.3
Variants
- Spend a fixed upgrade budget.
- Choose operations with different capacity costs.
- Find a new base after crafting capacity runs out.
Design example. A smith decides whether to spend the last crafting capacity on strength or keep a successful blade.
Companions, pets and mounts
62Companion levelingOverview and example ↗A companion has separate power, ability or role progression tied to shared activities.3
Variants
- Bring a companion into combat for experience.
- Train a specific role or ability.
- Upgrade companion-specific equipment.
Design example. A party healer earns expedition experience and unlocks group healing.
63Individual NPC relationshipsOverview and example ↗Repeated actions change an individual character's trust, unlocking reactions, services or quests.3
Variants
- Perform actions the character approves of.
- Give suitable gifts with bounded repeat effects.
- Complete shared quests for relationship milestones.
Design example. Helping an archivist with rare manuscripts unlocks a personal story and collection access.
64Pet trainingOverview and example ↗A pet develops commands, behavior or useful abilities through repeated practice.3
Variants
- Repeat exercises to learn commands.
- Use a pet ability in suitable situations.
- Develop a pet specialization instead of generic power.
Design example. A fox learns to find herbs as the player guides it through training trails.
65Mount trainingOverview and example ↗Riding, exercises or resources improve a particular mount's movement and capabilities.3
Variants
- Develop endurance through riding.
- Teach new movement abilities.
- Improve equipment and carrying capacity.
Design example. A mountain goat trains on slopes and gains the ability to reach a higher ledge.
66Breeding and inheritanceOverview and example ↗The player repeats parent selection and offspring raising for desired inherited traits.3
Variants
- Choose pairs by inheritable traits.
- Establish a rare trait in a lineage.
- Exchange offspring to broaden parent selection.
Design example. A breeder crosses fast and enduring animals while preserving successful lines.
67Hatching and raising creaturesOverview and example ↗Eggs or young creatures require conditions and care before becoming usable companions or collectibles.3
Variants
- Acquire eggs and provide incubation conditions.
- Raise a creature through several stages.
- Choose care affecting the eventual specialization.
Design example. The player maintains incubator warmth and feeds a newly hatched dragon.
Reputation, access and knowledge
68Faction reputationOverview and example ↗Repeated help for a chosen faction raises standing or rank and unlocks faction-specific options.3
Action → reward
- Complete faction assignments → unlock vendors, abilities and rewards.
- Complete different assignment types for one faction.
- Choose a side when standings conflict.
Design example. Delivering supplies to researchers raises trust and unlocks a map of hidden caves for purchase.
69Token accumulationOverview and example ↗Activities award a dedicated currency that can be exchanged for a chosen reward at a known price.3
Action → reward
- Complete activities awarding guaranteed currency → buy desired equipment.
- Accumulate tokens through several alternative activities.
- Choose the next purchase by cost and build contribution.
Design example. Each expedition grants two tokens; the hero can buy chosen gloves for twenty tokens.
70Key and ticket collectionOverview and example ↗One repeatable activity awards consumable access to another. A key establishes the cost of attempting the next reward.3
Action → reward
- Farm available activities → gain entry attempts to a boss or dungeon.
- Collect named key parts from different sources.
- Allocate limited passes among rewards.
Design example. Three seals from border outposts combine into a treasury key.
71Settlement developmentOverview and example ↗Contributing materials and completing orders develop a shared base, unlocking buildings, services or upgrades.3
Action → reward
- Contribute resources and complete orders → build workshops and unlock services.
- Develop workshops for new production options.
- Choose building order according to character needs.
Design example. The player delivers wood and stone for a smithy, unlocking equipment repairs in the settlement.
72Recipe researchOverview and example ↗Repeated work with samples gradually unlocks knowledge that expands available crafting options.3
Action → reward
- Find samples, dismantle items or experiment → unlock recipes.
- Study ingredient properties through experiments.
- Dismantle found samples to reconstruct a blueprint.
Design example. Researching collected poisons fills a study track and unlocks an antidote recipe.
Collections and metaprogression
78Collectible completionOverview and example ↗Repeatable activities fill a collection that can award cosmetic distinctions, records or completion rewards.3
Action → reward
- Repeat associated activities → collect appearances, pets, mounts and trophies.
- Complete a bestiary, appearance library or trophy set.
- Exchange duplicates for missing collection pieces.
Design example. The player visits different beast lairs to complete a bestiary and earn a camp decoration.
79Prestige and rebirthOverview and example ↗After reaching a threshold, the player resets part of their progression and repeats the journey with a permanent reward or new conditions.3
Action → reward
- Repeat a progression cycle after a partial reset → gain permanent bonuses or options.
- Carry a permanent bonus through a level reset.
- Unlock new rules for the next cycle.
Design example. At the level cap, a hero can be reborn, losing levels but keeping an unlocked extra talent slot.
80Tiered achievementsOverview and example ↗A theme has successive quantitative or qualitative thresholds with separate rewards.3
Variants
- Accumulate actions toward the next tier.
- Complete a set of different subtasks.
- Improve result quality for a higher distinction.
Design example. Solo hunting awards a beginner badge, then a title for a difficult series.
81New Game PlusOverview and example ↗A completed campaign restarts with specified progression carryover and changed conditions.3
Variants
- Carry some equipment into a new cycle.
- Unlock new difficulties after the ending.
- Collect mutually exclusive outcomes across playthroughs.
Design example. A hero retains skills but restarts with tougher encounters and new rewards.
82Seasonal progression journeyOverview and example ↗A set of repeated and one-off tasks organizes a season into a sequence of goals.3
Variants
- Complete chapters of seasonal goals.
- Accumulate seasonal experience on a reward track.
- Choose seasonal goals matching a preferred play style.
Design example. A seasonal journal asks players to learn new crafting, clear trials and earn a commemorative appearance.
Rewards
Delivery and distribution
83Guaranteed payoutOverview and example ↗Each successful repetition awards a known contribution, making the remaining path estimable.3
Variants
- Award a fixed resource for completion.
- Give a base reward plus optional bonuses.
- Fill a known track for each successful step.
Design example. Each delivery always awards one seal, and a purchase costs ten seals.
84Weighted random rewardsOverview and example ↗The result is drawn from a probability distribution; attempt frequency and table composition determine the path to a goal.3
Variants
- Use an independent table for each attempt.
- Choose rewards through several sequential rolls.
- Separate tables by region or difficulty.
Design example. A chest selects item type, then quality, then properties.
85Personal and shared lootOverview and example ↗The rule determines who owns a reward and how participants divide a shared outcome.3
Variants
- Award independent loot to each participant.
- Allocate a shared item through claims or rotation.
- Allow loot trading within the party.
Design example. Each participant receives personal materials, while a rare trophy is allocated separately.
86Reward choice offersOverview and example ↗After a repeatable activity, the player selects from a limited offer rather than receiving a fully random reward.3
Variants
- Choose one item from several random offers.
- Specify a reward category before starting.
- Receive a chest allowing selection of a specific item.
Design example. After an expedition, the player can take one of three displayed items.
87Performance-based rewardsOverview and example ↗Reward amount or composition depends on observable performance rather than completion alone.3
Variants
- Reward speed while preserving required conditions.
- Count preserved resources or allies.
- Give a separate bonus for an optional objective.
Design example. Preserved caravan crates increase the escort payout.
Investment and outcome protection
88Hard pity thresholdOverview and example ↗After a defined number of qualifying failures, the next reward is guaranteed under explicit counter rules.3
Variants
- Guarantee a reward on a defined attempt.
- Keep a separate counter for each target type.
- Preserve the counter across sessions or qualifying sources.
Design example. If a blueprint is not found in nine expeditions, the tenth guarantees it.
89Duplicate protectionOverview and example ↗The system tracks previous results and reduces or excludes unwanted duplicates.3
Variants
- Exclude owned items until a set is complete.
- Increase weights for missing categories.
- Allow replacement of a duplicate result.
Design example. A collection chest first awards banners not yet obtained.
90Increasing chance after failuresOverview and example ↗Probability changes with qualifying attempt history without necessarily providing a fixed guarantee.3
Variants
- Increase chance after every failure.
- Increase chance only after an initial threshold.
- Limit the increase to a known maximum.
Design example. Each failed attempt adds rare-reagent chance, and success resets the bonus.
91Unwanted-reward compensationOverview and example ↗A result unsuitable for the current goal retains value through replacement or alternative progress.3
Variants
- Exchange an unsuitable result for part of a chosen reward's cost.
- Award compensation currency alongside a duplicate.
- Allow accumulated replacement of several unwanted rewards.
Design example. An unwanted relic grants an exchange mark toward a chosen relic.
92Upgrade refunds and protectionOverview and example ↗Rules preserve part of an investment when replacing an item, failing or changing progression direction.3
Variants
- Refund some resources when salvaging an upgraded item.
- Consume protection to prevent loss of an enhancement level.
- Transfer accumulated levels to another base.
Design example. When replacing a sword, the player transfers much of its enhancement investment to the new one.
Scaling and focusing
93Risk-reward scalingOverview and example ↗The player accepts extra threats or restrictions in exchange for changed rewards.3
Variants
- Choose difficulty with a separate loot table.
- Add optional dangerous modifiers.
- Carry valuable cargo for a larger payout.
Design example. Before an expedition, the player can strengthen enemies for more rare materials.
94Streak multipliersOverview and example ↗Consecutive successes within a loop increase rewards until a reset or voluntary stop.3
Variants
- Raise a multiplier through consecutive victories.
- Preserve a streak while meeting a special condition.
- Bank an accumulated bonus when leaving the chain.
Design example. A party continues fights without returning to town to preserve its multiplier.
95Rested progression reserveOverview and example ↗Rest or absence builds a bounded reserve that accelerates later active actions.3
Variants
- Accumulate bonus-experience reserves while away.
- Spend the reserve only on qualifying actions.
- Use separate reserves for professions or combat.
Design example. After resting, the hero earns increased experience until a rested reserve is spent.
96Parallel goal progressionOverview and example ↗One activity meaningfully advances several independent goals, allowing useful combinations.3
Variants
- Combine a contract, experience and desired loot.
- Plan a route for multiple collections.
- Choose an activity by the current set of goals.
Design example. A hunt provides companion experience, ingredients and faction-contract progress at once.
97Loot-pool focusingOverview and example ↗The player invests resources or makes a choice to change eligible rewards or their relative weights.3
Variants
- Restrict the table to a chosen item type.
- Add a desired category to the table through investment.
- Change relative weights at the cost of other outcomes.
Design example. Before a ritual, the hero chooses a weapon school, narrowing rewards to that type.
Constraints
Schedule and pacing
98Daily cyclesOverview and example ↗A periodic reset refreshes objectives or bonuses and establishes repetition cadence.3
Variants
- Refresh a daily objective set.
- Award a bonus for the first daily completion.
- Allow selection of several tasks from a daily set.
Design example. One bonus order for a chosen profession becomes available each day.
99Weekly caps and reward eligibilityOverview and example ↗A period permits a limited number of rewards or currency units regardless of run count.3
Variants
- Cap valuable currency earned per period.
- Separate activity access from reward eligibility.
- Choose which rewards consume a periodic allowance.
Design example. A player may help friends raid, but receives personal chests only up to a weekly limit.
100Regenerating attempt budgetOverview and example ↗Activities consume a resource restored over time or through play, limiting repetition frequency.3
Variants
- Spend energy per attempt.
- Use separate budgets for different activities.
- Accumulate a bounded reserve for a longer session.
Design example. A hero has a gathering stamina reserve and chooses the most needed veins.
101Source respawn windowsOverview and example ↗A harvested source returns according to time or world-state rules, changing repeat availability.3
Variants
- Respawn each source separately.
- Refresh an entire area on a shared cycle.
- Trigger restoration through world events.
Design example. After mining ore, the player moves elsewhere until veins return.
102Production time constraintsOverview and example ↗Crafting or research takes time, requiring queue and capacity management.3
Variants
- Give each operation a duration.
- Limit parallel work slots.
- Allow periodic production of a rare component.
Design example. A laboratory studies one recipe while a workshop processes metal.
103Seasonal partial resetsOverview and example ↗A new season resets specified tracks or the economy while preserving stated outcomes.3
Variants
- Start a separate seasonal economy.
- Refresh the cycle's rules and goals.
- Transfer specified results into a permanent mode.
Design example. Seasonal heroes start without gold but retain commemorative appearances from earlier seasons.
104Catch-up progressionOverview and example ↗A behind or returning player accesses earlier stages at reduced cost or increased speed.3
Variants
- Increase rewards up to a defined threshold.
- Accumulate missed periodic opportunities.
- Reduce the cost of previous progression tiers.
Design example. A late-starting hero earns extra tokens until reaching baseline equipment.
Cost and risk
105Diminishing returnsOverview and example ↗Prolonged repetition of one source reduces yield or raises cost, changing the next activity choice.3
Variants
- Reduce yield when repeating one action.
- Raise the cost of consecutive upgrades.
- Restore efficiency after changing activities or resting.
Design example. After intensive harvesting, a site depletes and another becomes more attractive.
106Progress loss on failureOverview and example ↗Defeat removes resources, experience or some loot, making preservation part of the loop.3
Variants
- Lose some unbanked loot.
- Recover losses by returning to the defeat site.
- Risk the current character in a permanent-loss mode.
Design example. A defeated hero leaves a purse at the death site and decides whether to recover it.
107Banking and extractionOverview and example ↗Expedition gains become persistent only after exiting or reaching a banking point.3
Variants
- Leave a dangerous zone to preserve loot.
- Bank part of the result at intermediate checkpoints.
- Spend resources to send loot safely home.
Design example. A party chooses to exit with its ore or open another dangerous chamber.
108Item binding and circulationOverview and example ↗Transfer rules determine whether trade can replace personal farming and when an item leaves circulation.3
Variants
- Bind an item on acquisition or use.
- Allow transfer only within an account or party.
- Preserve free trade for selected categories.
Design example. A sword can be sold before equipping, then becomes bound to the hero.
109Capacity and stock managementOverview and example ↗Limited inventory or storage requires choices about keeping, processing, transporting or abandoning goods.3
Variants
- Limit carried weight or item count.
- Expand storage as a long-term goal.
- Choose when to return and unload.
Design example. A miner abandons cheap ore to make room for rare crystals.
110Shared-reward eligibilityOverview and example ↗Contribution, party and access rules determine who receives the result of a shared activity.3
Variants
- Count different useful roles for rewards.
- Require a minimum meaningful contribution.
- Normalize rewards when helping players of another level.
Design example. Caravan defense counts support for allies rather than damage alone.
Coverage map: four layers
The reference covers the main design axes, while combinations create further loops. Layers distinguish a new activity from a different goal or reward rule.
1. What repeats
Combat and hunting; raids, dungeons, waves, events and PvP; gathering, fishing, farming and production; searching, excavation and theft; trade and services; workers, dispatch, offline accumulation and logistics. Direct execution and managing delegated work create different decisions.
2. What accumulates or unlocks
Levels, skills, classes and talents; desired items and properties; upgrades and inserts; companions, relationships, pets and mounts; reputation, keys, recipes and settlements; region, guild and account; collections, achievements, rebirth and repeated campaigns.
3. How outcomes are determined
Guaranteed or random delivery, reward choice, personal or shared loot and performance; failure guarantees, duplicate protection, compensation and investment refunds; bonuses for risk, streaks, rest, parallel goals and pool focusing. These modify a loop rather than necessarily adding player actions.
4. What sets cost and cadence
Daily and weekly periods, energy, source recovery, production duration, seasons and catch-up; diminishing returns, defeat, extraction, binding, capacity and group eligibility. For each system, determine whether it constrains entry, rewards, speed or persistence.
Combining mechanics
Here, grinding means repeated actions for accumulation or progression. The catalog spans several design layers, so families can overlap.
Activity, goal and reward rule
First choose an activity: combat, gathering or crafting. Then choose a goal: a level, item, access or collection. Separately decide how rewards arrive: guaranteed, random or through an accumulation track. A dungeon is an activity format, a set is a goal, and tokens are a way to approach it.
Example combination
Illustration: monster hunts offer a random chance of a legendary blade and a guaranteed fragment per victory. Ten fragments can craft the blade. This combines targeted farming, random loot and an accumulated reward; the numbers are illustrative.
Schedules and limits
Daily quests, weekly caps, energy and timed events schedule activities or limit attempts. They can modify different loops in this list. Waiting for a timer does not itself add a new player action.
Rewards and prototype checks
The following questions help evaluate a chosen loop. These are design recommendations, not findings from completed research.
Visible progress
Show the goal, current contribution and cost of the next step. For random loot, decide whether fragments, tokens or exchange should provide a guaranteed path. With independent attempts and reward chance p, the probability of at least one reward after n attempts is 1 − (1 − p)^n. This is a probability, not a promise of a reward by a particular attempt.
Choices within repetition
Check whether the player can choose a route, difficulty, build or reward type. Changing numbers without changing decisions may lose its appeal quickly; test this hypothesis with players of the specific prototype.
Session boundaries and cost
Let players end a session after a clear step and see saved progress. Estimate the goal’s full cost including keys, consumables, failed attempts and return trips. For enhancement, state any intended risk of losing materials or the item in advance.
A small prototype check
Build one loop with one long-term goal. Ask the player what the next repetition will award and why they want to continue. Record the actual time to an upgrade, attempts without a useful reward and the voluntary stopping point, then revisit reward costs and composition.
Released-game examples
Primary sources were checked on 20 October 2026. Observations below concern the stated systems; historical notes are labeled separately. Numbers in hypothetical examples are not these games’ balance values.
Warframe: overall rank through equipment mastery
Warframe’s official support describes overall Mastery progression from ranking up different Warframes and weapons. A duplicate of an already counted item does not award that progress again. This exemplifies equipment breadth, not every progression option in this catalog.
Final Fantasy XIV: exchanging currency for equipment
Final Fantasy XIV’s official guide lists vendors exchanging Allagan tomestones and similar tokens for weapons, gear and items. This supports reward selection through currency exchange; the catalog’s illustrative prices are not game values.
Black Desert: nodes and workers
The Nodes guide describes connecting discovered nodes through contribution and dispatching workers for natural resources. This exemplifies network development and delegated gathering.
Black Desert: accumulated guarantee
The 9 January 2025 update describes Ancient Anvil activation after sufficient Agris Essence and guaranteed success for the corresponding enhancement. This is a historical hard-pity example; current thresholds are not asserted here.
Last Epoch: donor items and potential
Official Legendary Items support describes combining unique and exalted items with property transfer bounded by Legendary Potential. This exemplifies separate base and donor acquisition rather than a universal crafting rule.
The Elder Scrolls Online: effectiveness and trust
Official support distinguishes increased companion effectiveness through shared combat from rapport gained through approved actions. Stronger relationships can unlock personal quests.
Guild Wars 2: scheduled goals and choice
The official Wizard’s Vault description connects objectives on different schedules to the shared Astral Acclaim currency and reward choice. It also describes retaining past exclusive rewards in a legacy section.
Final Fantasy XIV: delegated gathering
Official 2.2 notes assign ventures to retainers who return with items. This is a historical dispatch example; old restrictions in those notes are not imported as current rules.
Combinations for different RPGs
These are hypothetical patterns, not descriptions of specific released games. A prototype can start with one core activity and one clear long-term goal.
ARPG: a build item
Pack clearing or a chosen boss → hunt for a base and properties → transfer an effect and enhance. Random loot can be complemented by fragments; repeat costs include consumables and access preparation.
MMORPG: parallel goals
Faction contract → party dungeon → tokens, reputation and companion experience. Purchase choice provides directed progress; a weekly cap applies to rewards if participation remains available afterward.
Economic RPG: a supply chain
Gathering or workers → processing → transport → sale or order. Calculate profit after inputs, consumables, fees, losses and delivery time; higher revenue alone does not establish profitability.
Exploration RPG: finds and knowledge
Treasure map → landmark search → excavation → item restoration → collection or recipe. Repetition can vary the route and search problem while preserving accumulated knowledge.
Party RPG: a roster and relationships
Shared expeditions → companion abilities and trust → personal quests and new party combinations. Relationship rank and combat effectiveness are separate tracks even when one activity advances both.
Extraction RPG: preserve the haul
Explore a dangerous area → accumulate cargo → choose another target or an exit → bank the result. Capacity, defeat probability and available banking locations change the decision to continue.
Management and offline-progression RPG
Develop a base → assign workers → queue production → bounded accumulation while absent → invest in the bottleneck. Distinguish active player decisions from automatic time-based awards.
Boundaries and related mechanics
Comprehensiveness here means coverage of the main systems, not enumeration of every possible combination. An activity appearing in an RPG is not enough to make it grinding: repetition, accumulation goals and persistence rules matter.
Activities and goals can share names
Fishing describes an activity, the fishing profession describes progression, a fish collection describes a goal, and a daily bonus describes reward delivery. Enhancement and skill development couple actions to particular tracks; their placement follows the dominant goal without claiming independence from other layers.
Looting, rerolling and transfer
Hunting perfect rolls requires new drops. Rerolling changes an owned item. Transfer requires a donor or saved effect. Crafting potential limits operations. These can lead to the same item but use different inputs and decisions.
Post-cap growth and restarting
A post-cap track continues development without a mandatory reset. Rebirth trades some progress for a permanent benefit. New Game Plus repeats a campaign with carryover. A seasonal reset establishes a shared new cycle and need not preserve the same outcomes.
Fragments, guarantees and increasing chance
Fragments provide visible accumulation. Hard pity bounds qualifying failures. Increasing chance changes the distribution but does not promise an outcome without a separate threshold. For variable chance, use the probability history; the independent constant-p formula does not apply.
Player skill and accumulation tracks
Winning through combat mastery or increasing skill rating is not necessarily grinding. The PvP section covers cumulative rewards for matches and contribution. One-off stories, irreversible final choices and waiting without a decision are not counted as separate grind activities.
System coverage and pacing audit
Answer these questions for the chosen loop and identify intentionally absent systems. Coverage checking does not mean every mechanic belongs in one game.
Entry, repetition and completion
What starts an attempt? Which decision changes on repetition? What persists after leaving, defeat and a season change? Can the player finish the goal or voluntarily change activities?
Time to outcome and variation
Separate active play, preparation, waiting and delivery. For random rewards, assess the median and long tail rather than only the average. Account separately for table size, duplicates, entry costs and guarantees.
Sources, sinks and exchange
Where do currency and materials enter and leave? Can another player’s farming output be purchased? What happens to stocks and prices as players become supplied? Check fees, binding, upgrade refunds and obsolete currencies.
Rest, returning and resets
What happens after missing a day or a month? Can opportunities accumulate, and is there a clear catch-up path? Do guarantees and earned results survive reward-table, season and version changes?
Sources and examples
Sources support particular techniques or methodology, not every family variant. Design examples and mechanic combinations are illustrative.
- Warframe: Mastery Basics
Official support on overall progression from ranking different Warframes and weapons and counting each item once. Supports the equipment-breadth example.
- Final Fantasy XIV: Exchanging Tomestones
Official guide to exchanging tomestones and similar tokens for weapons, gear and items. Supports the example of selecting rewards through currency.
- Black Desert: Nodes
Official guide to connecting nodes, contribution and dispatching workers for resources. Supports only the node and worker example.
- Black Desert: Ancient Anvil, 9 January 2025 update
Historical official description of accumulated Agris Essence and guaranteed enhancement at a threshold. Numerical thresholds are not imported into this reference.
- Last Epoch: Legendary Items
Official support on combining unique and exalted items and transferring properties according to Legendary Potential.
- The Elder Scrolls Online: Companions
Official support on shared combat, relationship development and companion personal quests.
- Guild Wars 2: Wizard’s Vault rewards
Official explanation of objectives on different schedules, shared currency and reward choice. Used as a structural example without current prices.
- Final Fantasy XIV: Retainer Ventures introduced in 2.2
Official historical notes on assigning gathering tasks to retainers. Their old caps and requirements are not presented as current.
CC BY 4.0 · gamemechanics.pro contributors